Logo

Defender of your Digital Freedom

Home > Internet Governance > TRAI Consultation on OTT Regulation – Follow-up Submission on Surveillance Reform
Surveillance, TRAI, OTT, SFLC.in, Puttaswamy

TRAI Consultation on OTT Regulation – Follow-up Submission on Surveillance Reform

Jun 13,2019 | 06:15 am

On 20 May 2019, during TRAI’s ‘Open House Discussion’ in Delhi on OTT communication services, certain arguments were raised regarding national security concerns surrounding encrypted communication services, including those services that have end-to-end encryption. The prime factor in these arguments was that terrorists could use end-to-end encrypted communication services to securely communicate among themselves, and such communication cannot be intercepted in time to gather intelligence and act swiftly. It was stated that if all communication could be intercepted in real-time, then terrorist activities could be prevented.

If one places themselves in the shoes of a sovereign that has the responsibility to protect the country from external threats, the prospect of legally requiring an app or a service to hand over all data or information is alluring. After all, this has been done for more than a century with letters, telegram and telephone. Letters could be opened, and telephone and telegram networks could be tapped. Why then, one might wonder, should digital services be treated any differently?

By way of a follow-up submission to TRAI on its public consultation on a regulatory framework for OTT communication platforms, we have addressed the technical and legal concerns around mass monitoring of online communication and the need for reforming surveillance law in India.

Our submission to TRAI can be downloaded below. Our comments and counter comments to TRAI’s public consultation on OTT communication services can be downloaded from – here and here, respectively.

Representation sent to Arunchal Pradesh

A newspaper article dated 30.10.2020 published in Telegraph India titled ‘Arunachal Internet Bar to curb Cheating’ stated that Arunachal Pradesh government will be ...

Letter to Telangana Government Against Mandatory Aadhaar Data for Non-Agricultural Land Records

Letter to Telangana Government Against Mandatory Aadhaar Data for Non-Agricultural Land Records As Telangana's Dharani Portal goes live today, we wrote ...

Letter to the Kerala Government to Reconsider the Proposal for Amending the Kerala Police Act by inserting Section 118 (A)

Letter to Kerala Government to Reconsider the Proposal for Amending the Kerala Police Act by inserting Section 118 (A) SFLC.in sent ...

Event – Creating Safe Spaces Online

SFLC.in in collaboration with Trust Law, Thompson Reuters Foundation is hosting a 2 day event on 'Creating Safe Spaces Online' on 21st-22nd ...

SFLC.in writes to the Criminal Reforms Committee

SFLC.in sent its recommendations to the Criminal Reforms Committee on 16th September 2020. Our recommendations covered criminal sanctions against free speech ...

Update on Anivar A Aravind v. Ministry of Home Affairs, GM PIL WP (C) 7483 of 2020

Update on Anivar A Aravind v. Ministry of Home Affairs, GM PIL WP (C) 7483 of 2020 SFLC.in’s advisory board ...

Our Comments on Draft Health Data Management Policy of the National Digital Health Mission

Our Comments on Draft Health Data Management Policy of the National Digital Health Mission The Ministry of Health and Family ...

Our Comments on the Non-Personal Data Governance Framework Report

Our Comments on the Non-Personal Data Governance Framework Report A committee of experts under the Chairpersonship of Mr. Kris Gopalakrishnan ...

Letter to the Standing Committee on Information Technology on Content Moderation by Social Media Platforms

SFLC.in has written to the Standing Committee on Information Technology chaired by Dr. Shashi Tharoor on the Content Moderation policies ...

Report from the panel discussion on “Reconciling State’s Interest With a Digital Life”

Report from the panel discussion on “Reconciling State’s Interest With a Digital Life” Software Freedom Law Centre (SFLC.in) in collaboration ...