Defender of your Digital Freedom

Home > Digital Privacy > Income Tax Returns filing sans Aadhaar

Income Tax Returns filing sans Aadhaar

Jul 26,2018 | 07:15 am

Aadhaar Free Income Tax Return Filing; Courtesy Delhi High Court

As July 31, 2018, the deadline to file Income Tax returns for the Assessment Year 2018 – 2019, comes closer, the complexities and jargon behind whether or not Aadhaar Registration/ Enrollment ID (Aadhaar Number) has to be furnished/ linked become more and more relevant by the minute. Thankfully for us, the Delhi High Court has come to save the day.

The Delhi High Court, on Tuesday in the case of Shreyasen & Anr. v. Union of India[fn]W.P. (C) 7444/2018, C.M. APPL. No. 28499/2018[/fn] cleared all the hullabaloo regarding the “linking” and “furnishing” of one’s Aadhaar number which was previously mandated to file income tax returns.

In its order, the Delhi High Court directed the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) to, at least till the period of March 31, 2019, either create a platform by amending the digital form or substituting the same to properly enable “opt out” from the mandatory requirement of having to furnish Aadhaar number.

This effectively means that no Aadhaar Number, previously mandated (either the 12-digit Aadhaar Card registration number or the 28-digit Aadhaar Card Enrollment ID), will be required to file income tax returns.

Progression of the Issue

Section 139AA(1) of the Income-Tax Act, 1961 as inserted by the Finance Act, 2017[fn]http://pib.nic.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=160538[/fn] is what gave teeth to the previously ongoing mandatory quoting of Aadhaar number for filing income tax returns. The constitutionality of the same was upheld by the Supreme Court of India in the case of Binoy Viswam v. Union of India & Ors.[fn]W.P. (C) 247/2017[/fn]

However, only a partial stay was granted by the Supreme Court in Binoy Viswam v. Union of India & Ors. for the purposes of Section 139AA(2) which talked about how every person who had been allotted PAN as on the 1st day of July, 2017, and who was eligible to obtain Aadhaar, would have to intimate their Aadhaar on or before a date to be notified by the Central Government failing which the PAN allotted to the person would be deemed to be invalid. However, the Supreme Court also stated that PAN cards of assessees, those who were not Aadhaar card holders, would not be invalidated.

Meanwhile, an order was passed in the Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India case (commonly known as the Right to Privacy case)(“Puttaswamy case”)[fn]W.P. (C) 494/2012[/fn] which put a stay on the linkage of Aadhaar Number with various services other than those mentioned in Section 7 of the Aadhaar (Targeted Delivery of Financial and other Subsidies, Benefits and Services) Act, 2016 and filing of income tax returns under Section 139AA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 till the final disposal of the matter.[fn]https://www.supremecourtofindia.nic.in/supremecourt/2012/35071/35071_2012_Order_15-Dec-2017.pdf.[/fn]

Vide its circular dated July 31, 2017, which was the initial deadline to submit Aadhaar, the CBDT extended the deadline to August 31, 2017[fn] https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/Lists/Latest News/Attachments/181/Order-under-section-119-of-the-Income-tax-Act-1961-31-07-2017.pdf[/fn] which was further extended to December 31, 2017.[fn]https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/Lists/Press%20Releases/Attachments/676/Press-Release-CBDT-extends-date-Linking-Aadhaar-with-PAN-8-12-2017.pdf.[/fn] On March 27, 2018, the CBDT extended the deadline again to June 30, 2018, citing that the same had been done on account of “consideration of the matter”.[fn]https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/Lists/Press%20Releases/Attachments/698/Press-Release-CBDT-extends-date%20for-Linking-of-Aadhaar-with-PAN-27-03-2018.pdf[/fn]

On March 31, 2018, the Ministry of Finance issued a circular stating that the date of submission of Aadhaar Number was extended till the time the pronouncement of the final judgement of the Puttaswamy case[fn]http://egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2018/184377.pdf[/fn] and finally on June 30, 2018, another notification by the CBDT, extended the deadline for linking PAN with Aadhaar Number was extended to March 31, 2019.[fn]https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/news/cbdt-order-regarding-linking-of-pan-with-aadhaar-while-filing-of-itrs-30-06-2018.pdf[/fn]

This led to a conflicting situation where on one hand, the CBDT had stated that linking was to be done only by March 31, 2019, but at the same time income tax returns could not be filed without quoting Aadhaar number. The differentiation lay in the fine print i.e. the difference between “quoting” one’s Aadhaar number versus “linking” ones Aadhaar number.

Numerous litigations arose across various High Courts of the country including the Delhi High Court[fn]W.P. (C) 3212/2018[/fn], Punjab and Haryana High Court[fn]WP 7672/2018[/fn], Madras High Court[fn]W.P. 27826/2017[/fn], and the Kerala High Court[fn]WP(C). No. 26033/2017(D)[/fn] all of which allowed the petitioners specifically, to file their income tax returns without “quoting” their Aadhaar numbers which the Income Tax department had said was mandatory and was different from “linking” the deadline for which had been extended.

In this backdrop, the only solution that an individual could take recourse to non-quoting of their Aadhaar number was filing a suit and praying for the same outcome. The Shreyasen & Anr. v. Union of Indiacase is however, different in the sense that it not only orders the CBDT to create a platform by amending the digital form or substituting the same to properly enable “opt out” from the mandatory requirement of having to furnish Aadhaar number but more importantly it does not restrict its scope to the petitioners alone.

Awaiting CBDT Compliance

In what is probably a staged rollout, there have been instances wherein some users are already being able to file their income tax returns online without quoting their Aadhaar Number.

With the deadline to file income tax returns coming extremely close, SFLC.in is closely monitoring CBDT’s strict compliance with the Delhi High Court order; with sources confirming that the same is to take place for all users in the next 24 hours.

Please do note that at the time of publication of this blog post, quoting of Aadhaar Number is still mandated in our sample account hereunder.


Letter To The Standing Committee on Information Technology

Recommendations to The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Information Technology for Surveillance Reforms in lieu of WhatsApp-NSO Revelations Recommendations sent to Dr. ...

Follow-up Comments on the Consultation on Draft Personal Data Protection Bill, 2018

On August 20, 2019 we learned that the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) was conducting a follow-up consultation on ...

Truecaller automatically retrieved bank account details of its users and registered them for UPI

Reports came out on Tuesday that the Truecaller app had sent SMS messages from phones of unsuspecting users to create UPI ...

Roundtable on ‘Policy Enabling – Information Technology in Healthcare’

We are organising an invite-only round table discussion on 'Policy Enabling - Information Technology in Healthcare' in Bangalore on 27 ...

What has been changed in the Aadhaar Amendment Bill?

On Wednesday, 02 January 2019, we got our first look at The Aadhaar and Other Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2018. On ...

The Aadhaar and Other Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2018

  Today, the Central Government introduced, The Aadhaar and Other Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2018 in the Lok Sabha. The Bill ...

Someone still asking for Aadhaar? Let us know!

Contrary to the Supreme Court’s judgment, some entities are still asking for Aadhaar A nine judge bench of the Supreme ...

FAQs on the Aadhaar Judgment

1. Can Aadhaar be required for getting a new mobile connection? Is linking Aadhaar with mobile number mandatory? No. The ...

Key Highlights of the Aadhaar Judgment

The Supreme Court has delivered its much awaited judgment in the Aadhaar case, wherein the majority view, comprised of - ...

Full text of the 1448-page Aadhaar Judgement

The Supreme Court has delivered its much awaited judgment in the Aadhaar case, wherein the majoirty view, comprised of -  ...